Welcome to the Age of Receipts
I don’t know if there has ever been a more surreal moment in the technology industry. It’s the front page of the paper, every single day. We’ve got Jensen Huang’s affairs (in all senses of the word), big systems going down daily, and a data-center-critical incoming Democratic Congress. We have a supposedly tech-forward presidential administration with no ability to even perceive how badly it screwed up, the impending trillion (or is it two?) dollar Anthropic IPO, and a sudden leftward tilt from tech billionaires, reminding us how progressive they are, really.
I don’t really need to run through each of these stories. You’re either aware of them or not—but odds are, you’re aware of all of them. Personally, that’s the thing that’s hardest to wrap my head around.
I find the tech industry inherently fascinating, and as a result I’ve spent a lot of my life explaining it to people who find it kind of boring and would like to understand all the fuss. But for the first time in my life, I’m confident that people will know what I’m talking about before I bring it up. Tech is constantly front-page national or global news, not exiled to the science or business sections of the paper. Tech policy is a de-facto part of politics. Whether I’m going to a lunch, a baby shower, or a school meeting, before I can offer a word, people tell me their opinions on Elon Musk, or Claude. Sometimes they’re really pissed off, sometimes they’re enamored, and very often, they’re totally wrong about some basic facts. But they are highly, highly engaged.
This moment of vigilance isn’t just about tech. When the Democrats neglected to vote on a motion to impeach Secretary of War Pete Hegseth—and to be fair, it would have been a pointless vote—much of their base was enraged. The message was: We expect you to be there, even if it’s just to go through the motions.
And then Alex Karp, CEO of Palantir, suddenly started insisting his blood runs blue. “I know more about being a progressive than almost anybody on the planet,” he told Politico, “and I absolutely believe Palantir—all of our products are essentially progressive.” Which, look, he’s kookytimes bananacakes, and we can all see that. But it led Elizabeth Lopatto in The Verge to gather all the times he did things like claiming that Palantir is “the first company to be completely anti-woke” on an earnings call, or bragging about his chats with “actual” Nazis.
Now, I love people being all engaged with the technology industry, because it makes me feel like less of a weirdo, and I’ve been hoping tech becomes part of political discourse forever. I’m glad to have my voice out there, of course, but I’m even more happy to learn that someone like Jasmine Sun is going to report on AI for the New York Times more steadily.
But more broadly, I do not believe that our current institutions are designed for this level of attention—Republican, Democratic, or Nvidian. Jensen Huang enjoyed operating in public as a superstar of capitalism, famed for his loyalty to his wife; he felt he had the freedom to do pretty much anything, and he also ponied up $25 million for the White House ballroom to keep it all rolling smoothly. Alex Karp has long been able to say whatever bonkers thing he wanted and it would get lost in the daily cacaphony—who cares what the Palantir guy says?
As for Anthropic, it’s going to have to tell the public markets what it did, what it plans to do, and how it’s going to make money with large enterprise clients. They are not going to really care about the god-computer stuff or the public benefit stuff. They’ll put up with it as long as the money comes in. It’s a level of scrutiny that the organization has never received before, but it’s tapped out private investment and needs to keep growing.
We’ve been living in an era of absolute, extreme noise. For a decade, the literal publicly stated strategy for a big chunk of our leadership class has been “flood the zone with shit.” That bought a lot of people a lot of cover to both say and do whatever the hell they wanted, and pile up tons and tons of money in the process. Social media is an incredible tool for flooding the zone, and it’s been used to extreme effect. Sure, people on Bluesky might moan and whine and share memes of guillotines, but ultimately, all you have to do is open more floodgates, and you can drown them out. If you’re not getting the narrative you want, just buy Twitter. If you’re a truly powerful tech capitalist, you need to control the means of sewage.
My sense, though, is that people are done with this. You can see it across other social networks, and you can find it in the group chat, and you can see it in the big blue wave. So I think it would be a huge mistake for tech leaders to assume they can operate as they have been. I wonder if the nature of “the zone” might have changed. It turns out that people don’t like living in a flood of shit after all. Good for us!
Elizabeth Lopatto closed her piece on Karp with some advice:
Anyway, for any other tech bros who want to do a less clumsy pivot than Karp, I have a suggestion. First, go to rehab, ideally for 90 days. Then come out and apologize for whatever it was you said between, I don’t know, 2020 and now. You feel very bad about what you’ve said, but it was the cocaine (or the amphetamines, or hell, blame it on ketamine, since the average person has no idea what a ketamine high looks like) speaking. You have dried out and sobered up. It was a challenge, but it was rewarding. You are now chastened. You want to work for public accountability. You are sorry about the dumb things you said while you were high.
Maybe that would work! I’d throw something else out, though: If there’s one thing I’ve learned from Silicon Valley, it’s that you should be willing to turn on a dime, disrupt the past, and move forward. They should take their own advice. The cultural infrastructure they built is now legacy. They need to disrupt it. There’s never been a better time to build.